Posted by In construction contracts, both earnest money deposits (EMDs) and security deposits serve to protect project owners and contractors. While they share the goal of ensuring contractual commitments, they arise at different stages, carry distinct purposes, and follow separate release conditions.
What Is an Earnest Money Deposit in Construction?
An earnest money deposit in construction, often called bid security or tender guarantee, is submitted by bidders alongside their tender. It signals the contractor’s commitment to honor the submitted bid and secure the contract award.
Earnest Money Deposit prevents incompetent contractors from bidding.
- Paid at bid submission to the project owner or procurement body
- Typically held by the owner or an escrow agent until contract award
- Forfeited if the bidder withdraws, revises price downward, or fails to sign the contract upon award
- Usually ranges from 1% to 5% of the tender value, depending on procurement regulations
What Is a Security Deposit in Construction?
A security deposit in construction, sometimes referred to as contract retention or performance security, is provided by the contractor after contract signing. It safeguards the owner against defective workmanship, delays, or non-performance.
- Collected at contract execution or via periodic withholdings from interim payments.
- Held by the owner or a designated trust until project completion and defect liability period ends.
- Deductions may cover unfinished works, rectification costs, or liquidated damages
- Often equals 5% to 10% of the contract sum, released in stages or upon final acceptance
| Aspect | Earnest Money Deposit (Bid Security) | Security Deposit (Retention/Performance) |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Ensure bid fidelity and bid withdrawal deterrence | Guarantee performance and defect correction |
| Timing | With tender submission | At contract award or via interim payment retention |
| Amount | 1–5% of bid value | 5–10% of contract value |
| Holding Method | Escrow, owner’s account, or bank guarantee | Owner-held trust account or bank guarantee |
| Forfeiture/Deductions | Bid withdrawal, non-acceptance of award | Uncorrected defects, delays, unpaid obligations |
| Release Conditions | Upon contract signing or bidder acceptance | After defects liability period or phased milestones |
Applications of Earnest Money Deposit
- Prequalifying serious bidders in public tenders
- Dissuading non-committal participants in competitive procurement
- Securing proposals for large-scale infrastructure projects
Applications of Security Deposit
- Withholding funds to ensure the contractor corrects defects during the liability period
- Compensating the owner for delayed milestones or incomplete deliverables
- Supplementing or replacing performance bonds under specific contract frameworks
Legal and Contractual Considerations
- Procurement rules often mandate acceptable forms of bid security (e.g., bank guarantees, certified checks)
- Standard forms like FIDIC, NEC, or AIA contracts detail deposit limits, release schedules, and dispute resolution
- Local statutes may cap retention percentages or require interest payments on withheld sums
- Clear contract clauses should define events of forfeiture, refund timelines, and documentation requirements
Best Practices for Owners and Contractors
- Owners should specify deposit amounts, acceptable instruments, and precise release milestones in the tender documents
- Contractors must verify guarantee validity periods and embed refund conditions in subcontracts when mobilizing specialist trades
- Both parties should track deposit releases using a project ledger to avoid accounting disputes
- Leverage digital escrow services or blockchain-based deposit tracking to enhance transparency and auditability
Beyond Deposits: Performance Bonds and Bank Guarantees
For high-value or high-risk projects, consider substituting or supplementing deposits with:
- Performance bonds issued by reputable sureties
- Advance payment guarantees secure mobilization funds
- Maintenance bonds covering post-completion warranty periods
Exploring these instruments can optimize liquidity, strengthen risk mitigation, and align contractual safeguards with project scope.
Read Also-
Engineering, Procurement, and Construction (EPC) in Civil Engineering
Types of Contracts in the Construction Industry
How to Become a Licensed Civil Contractor in USA?
How to Hire a Structure Engineer in USA? (2025 Guide)
Download National Building Code of India 2016 – Volume 1 & Volume 2